The Department of Labor made the proposal available on November 16, ahead of its scheduled publication in the Federal Register, the official record of federal rules, on November 17. It is a plan open to public comment, not a rule already in force.

Daylight Post found that the forecast shortage does not show whether a US nurse is available for a particular vacancy. We compared the federal forecast with the Labor Department’s proposal: one estimates future care needs, while the other would require a job-by-job check. The department also argues that the law does not let it exempt whole occupations.

What would change for a nurse?

A green card gives someone permission to live and work permanently in the United States. For many people applying through a job, the employer must first show that it cannot find enough able, willing and qualified US workers for that position. It must also show that hiring the foreign worker will not harm the pay and working conditions of similar US workers.

Professional nurses currently have an exemption from the first, job-by-job recruitment process. They are on a list called Schedule A, alongside physical therapists and certain other groups. The government has already accepted a shortage for these occupations, so eligible employers can send their case directly to US Citizenship and Immigration Services, the agency deciding immigration applications.

This route still has requirements. The employer needs a genuine permanent job offer, must meet wage rules and must notify staff or their union. The nurse must provide evidence of the required nursing qualifications. Meeting Schedule A rules does not by itself guarantee a green card.

The proposal would remove Schedule A. Employers sponsoring professional nurses would instead have to advertise and recruit under the usual permanent-job process, then seek Labor Department approval before the immigration petition. It would be an added step for the employer, not a new nursing exam.

Why the department wants US applicants checked

The department says the change would protect US workers’ access to jobs and fair wages. It argues that the nursing and physical therapy entries have stayed largely unchanged for more than 30 years.

It also says it lacks a reliable method to establish the nationwide shortage needed to keep waiving individual recruitment. More than 2,000 responses to an earlier request for evidence did not provide a method it considered adequate.

There is a separate legal argument. The department now says immigration law does not give it authority to exempt whole occupations from the job-market check. That is the department’s interpretation in this proposal. A forecast showing a shortage would not, on its own, answer that legal argument.

The forecast still points to a shortage

The federal Health Resources and Services Administration published its nursing projections in December 2025. Its main forecast puts the supply of registered nurses about 8% below demand in 2028. By 2038, the gap narrows to about 3%.

The 2028 figures imply a shortfall equivalent to 267,330 full-time nursing jobs. That is the difference between projected demand of 3,301,690 and supply of 3,034,360. These are amounts of work, based on a 40-hour week, rather than a count of that many individual people.

The forecast assumes past patterns of graduation, people leaving nursing and workforce participation continue. It also shows much larger projected shortages outside metropolitan areas. The national total can therefore hide very different conditions in different places.

A predicted national shortage cannot establish whether a qualified US nurse is willing and available for one particular vacancy now. Equally, requiring each employer to recruit again would remove a route designed to avoid repeating that check for shortage occupations. The proposal puts the balance between those two concerns back into each application.

A change to settlement, not an immediate loss of permission

For a nurse planning a lasting life in the US, the relevant change would be to the process for an employer-sponsored green card. The proposal itself does not cancel an existing work permit or remove nurses already working legally.

It is separate from the proposed change to how earlier approvals are treated when temporary work permission is extended. Temporary permission and permanent residence involve different decisions.

The government must consider public comments before deciding on a final rule. Our comparison establishes a proposed extra recruitment step alongside a forecast staffing gap. It does not establish how many nursing posts would go unfilled, or how much longer patients would wait for care if the plan went ahead.