Ebenezer Adodo paid £379 online for a laptop with Windows already installed. He collected it from an Argos counter in August 2024, took it home and checked whether it would work with the software he needed for work. It did not meet his needs. He brought it back five days after buying it, and the shop refused a refund.
On November 13, the Court of Appeal in England and Wales ordered Argos to repay the price of the laptop with interest. The University of Leicester, where Adodo teaches law, publicized the ruling on November 17. The case turns on what a shopper can reasonably do to check a product they agreed to buy before seeing it.
Daylight Post found that the ruling, the online returns rules and Argos’s current guidance distinguish three questions. Where the purchase was agreed determines whether the online cancellation rules apply. Setting up the laptop to check how it works does not, by itself, take away that right. More extensive handling can affect how much money the retailer has to return.
Picking up an order in a shop can still be an online purchase
Argos initially argued that this was not a sale made at a distance. The court found that the company had already accepted Adodo’s order in a confirmation email. The purchase was agreed online. The store was simply where he received the goods.
That distinction helps with click and collect, which lets shoppers order or reserve something online and pick it up in person. If the website only reserves an item and you decide whether to buy it at the counter, the sale may be agreed in the shop. The receipt and order confirmation can help show when the seller accepted the purchase.
Why switching on the laptop mattered
One exception to the cancellation right covers separately supplied computer software on a physically sealed medium, such as a disc, when the buyer opens the seal. The lower court had accepted that activating Windows broke what Argos called a digital seal.
The Court of Appeal treated the purchase as a computer with the software needed to make it work. It rejected the idea that activating that software to test the laptop was equivalent to opening a sealed copy of software. That matters because shoppers cannot see how a computer works by looking at its box or reading a list of specifications.
When a retailer can reduce the refund
For most goods bought online from a business, the UK rules give you 14 days after you receive the item to tell the seller you want to cancel. You then normally have another 14 days to send it back. These rules can apply when there is nothing wrong with the product.
The law allows a seller to deduct value the item lost because the shopper handled it more than was needed to see what it was and how it worked. The usual benchmark is what you could reasonably do in a shop. The seller must also have provided the required information about cancellation rights to make that deduction.
That is a different decision from whether a shopper can cancel at all. A brief check of how a computer runs is different from using it as your everyday machine for a fortnight. If handling beyond a reasonable check lowers its resale value, that loss can reduce the refund.
Argos’s current guidance lists a voluntary 30-day return policy with conditions such as keeping the item unused. It describes the legal right to cancel most online orders separately. If a return is refused under a shop’s own policy, ask which rule the shop is applying. The answer matters when you bought online and opened the box simply to see whether the product did what you needed.
